
ETHRA’s monthly roundup of news: Smoke-Free Environments decision imminent - DG SANTE reshuffle - Vapers Finland taxation statement - Acvoda consumer survey report - Spanish public consultation submissions - Evidence briefs for tobacco harm reduction - Examining the ‘Gateway’ Hypothesis - Country updates. Read on for more.
Contents:
EU Council recommendation on Smoke-Free Environments
It has been reported that the long-awaited update to the 2009 EU Council recommendation on Smoke Free Environments will be announced on 17 September.
European Commission Plans Again to Hollow Out DG SANTE
According to media reports DG SANTE, the EU’s health directorate, could lose some key roles. DG SANTE has responsibility for food security, tobacco, and alcohol. It’s still unclear whether any reshuffle would affect the upcoming review of the TPD.
Read more here:
https://www.eureporter.co/health/2024/07/31/confidence-in-health-tumbles-as-the-european-commission-plans-again-to-hollow-out-dg-sante/
COUNTRY UPDATES
Czechia
The Czech Health Ministry is drafting an amendment to a decree which could see the implementation of a vape flavour ban.
Read more here:
https://praguemorning.cz/czech-health-ministry-wants-to-ban-sweet-flavoured-electronic-cigarettes/
Finland
Vapers Finland add their submission to the government's Draft Law on Tobacco Tax.
Netherlands
ETHRA partner Acvoda published the results of its consumer survey into the effects of the Netherlands vape flavour ban and online sales ban.
Read more here:
https://acvoda.nl/2024/08/30/enquete-onder-nederlandse-dampers-over-de-gevolgen-van-het-online-verkoop-en-smaakverbod/
Poland
The Polish Ministry of Health plans to submit a bill to parliament in September 2024 which would apply the same regulations to non-nicotine vapes as nicotine-containing vapes.
Read more here:
https://vape1024.com/poland-sets-new-rules-for-nicotine-free-e-cigarettes-starting-2025/
Spain
The Ministry of Health’s public consultation on the Draft Law for the modification of Law 28/2005 closed on 15 August. The Draft Law aims to regulate consumption in public places, advertising and points of sale for safer nicotine products.
See ETHRA’s contribution:
https://ethra.co/images/ETHRA_submission_to_Spains_Draft_Law_for_the_modification_of_Law_282005.pdf
Submission from Dr Roberto A Sussman, Institute of Nuclear Sciences, is available (Spanish) here
See the submission from the Center Of Excellence For The Acceleration Of Harm Reduction (COEHAR):
https://www.coehar.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/CoEHAR_Spanish-consultation-Anti-Tobacco-law.pdf
Read more about the consultation here:
https://filtermag.org/spain-tobacco-harm-reduction/amp/
UK
The Daily Pouch discusses the reintroduction of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill. Topics covered include potential changes and key aspects of the Bill, concerns and consequences, a ban on disposable vapes, and taxation.
Read more here:
UK Vape Legislation State of Play – Part 1, The Tobacco and Vaping Bill
UK Vape Legislation State of Play – Part 2, The Disposable Ban and Vape Taxes
More from the UK
The British Medical Association published a report recommending stricter restrictions on safer nicotine products, which include a ban on disposable vapes and flavour restrictions. Experts including Professor Peter Hajek, express their concern.
Read more here:
https://www.sciencemediacentre.org/expert-reaction-to-new-report-on-regulation-of-vaping/
ETHRA was asked to comment on the recent report from the British Medical Association which recommended flavour restrictions and a ban on disposable vapes, among other things. Our comment is below:

Evidence briefs for tobacco harm reduction
Updated evidence briefs on the scientific and policy considerations for safer nicotine products that support tobacco harm reduction, from Clive Bates. Documents are available in English and Portuguese and are a must read for anyone involved in the field of tobacco control and tobacco harm reduction.
See the documents here:
https://clivebates.com/evidence/
The Case for Flavours
Planet of the Vapes takes a look at Dr Konstantinos Farsalinos’ The Case For Flavours In Tobacco Harm Reduction To Save Lives report.
Read more here:
https://www.planetofthevapes.co.uk/news/vaping-news/2024-08-21_the-case-for-flavours.html
Examining the ‘Gateway’ Hypothesis
Dr Michael Siegel writes: “The claim by opponents of e-cigarettes that vaping is a gateway to smoking and will increase the long-term hazards of tobacco product use have now been completely debunked by longitudinal trend data demonstrating that the truth is the exact opposite.”
Read more here:
https://tobaccoanalysis.blogspot.com/2024/08/new-data-show-that-e-cigarettes-are.html
Arielle Selya, PhD talks to Filter about her recent paper ““The ‘Gateway’ hypothesis: evaluation of evidence and alternative explanations.”
Read more here:
https://filtermag.org/youth-vaping-gateway-theory/
Read the paper here:
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12954-024-01034-6
Something to listen to:
SSA Conference 2024: Ann McNeill discusses tobacco harm reduction